Amazon Bedrock - Classic Agent vs AgentCore Agent
A Comparison: Amazon Bedrock - Classic Agents vs AgentCore Agents. This analysis provides a guideline that allows the developers to choose between Amazon Bedrock - Classic Agents and AgentCore Agents
Introduction
Amazon Bedrock has provided two ways to develop AI agents: Classic Agents and AgentCore.
Classic Agents is a property managed, declarative service whereby the user provides tools and knowledge bases and AWS takes care of orchestration, reasoning loops, and prompt management—great for fast deployment of common agentic workflows such as customer support or document processing.
AgentCore is, on the other hand, a low-level framework that enables you to fully control orchestration logic, state management, and agent coordination, which can be used for building complex multi-agent systems or in scenarios where custom reasoning patterns are required.
The trade-off is clear-cut: Classic Agents come with both speed and simplicity using the managed infrastructure, whereas AgentCore offers the utmost flexibility and control at the cost of increased ongoing development and maintenance.
Ultimately, your decision will be influenced by whether you want to deploy quickly with standard workflows or you need to have sophisticated custom agent architectures with profound control over the development process.
Agent offerings on Amazon Bedrock
Classic Agent
- Fully managed service. No code required to create basic Agent Loop
- Agent is created by selecting a Foundation model, and adding Action groups. After creation you can test out the Agent in real-time and create multiple versions.
AgentCore Agent
- Provides flexible infrastructure services, but requires more custom logic/development.
- It is based on Open Foundations and promotes use of Open Agentic AI Frameworks like Strands Agents, CrewAI, LangChain/LangGraph etc.
- Agents run on AgentCore Runtime
Agent offering Comparison: Classic vs AgentCore
Classic Agent | AgentCore Agent |
|---|---|
Fully managed service. No code required to create basic Agent Loop | Provides flexible infrastructure services, but requires more custom logic/development. |
No control over choice of Agentic Framework and uses a proprietary, configuration-based approach. | It is based on Open Foundations, works with any open-source framework (e.g., Strands Agents, CrewAI, LangGraph, LlamaIndex). |
Accesses foundation models available within Amazon Bedrock. | It is based on Open Foundations, Can use any foundation model, within or outside of Amazon Bedrock. |
Offers less customization, focusing on ease of use and no code development. | Highly customizable, allowing developers to write custom logic and control the architecture. |
Abstracts completely features like prompt engineering, memory, monitoring, encryption, user permissions, and API invocation. | Offers distinct, composable services for Runtime, Memory, Gateway, Identity, Observability, Code Interpreter, Browser, Policy, and Evaluations. |
Integrates with Tools via a concept called Action Groups and its associated configuration. | It is based on Open Foundations, uses open protocols like MCP, A2A to interface with Tools and Other Agents. It also has AgentCore Gateway component to transform APIs and Lambda functions into agent-compatible tools via open foundation protocol - Model Context Protocol (MCP). |
Agent offering: When to use which
Classic Agent: Best for scenarios where a simple, secure, and fully managed approach is preferred.
AgentCore Agent: Designed for developers who need enterprise-grade scale, security, and flexibility for agents built with custom frameworks.
Key Distinction:
- Classic Agent = "I have a clear workflow with well-defined tools, and I want AWS to handle orchestration"
- AgentCore = "I need multiple intelligent agents with custom coordination logic and can't be constrained by pre-built orchestration patterns"
Let's take a look at examples:
Enterprise Document Analysis & Compliance System: A financial services company needs an AI system to analyze loan application documents, extract key information, verify compliance with lending regulations, and generate approval recommendations. The system must: Parse multiple document types (PDFs, images, forms), Cross-reference data against internal databases, Check compliance rules from a knowledge base, Generate structured output for loan officers, Maintain audit trails of decision logic
Why Classic Agent Makes Sense:
- Pre-built orchestration: The managed orchestration layer handles the complex flow of parsing → verification → knowledge base lookup → decision generation without you writing coordination logic
- Built-in knowledge base integration: Native integration with Bedrock Knowledge Bases for RAG on compliance documentation
- Action groups with schemas: Well-defined OpenAPI schemas for database lookups and validation checks fit perfectly
- Session management: Built-in conversation memory for multi-turn interactions with loan officers
- Lower development overhead: You define tools and let Bedrock handle the ReAct loop, prompt templates, and error handling
Dynamic Multi-Agent Travel Disruption System - An airline needs a sophisticated disruption management system where multiple specialized agents collaborate in real-time during weather events or operational disruptions: Crew Agent: Monitors crew duty time regulations, finds available crew, Aircraft Agent: Tracks plane locations, maintenance windows, gate assignments Customer Agent: Manages rebooking, hotel vouchers, compensation policies Operations Agent: Coordinates gate changes, cancellations, crew swaps. These agents must negotiate solutions dynamically - for example, if the Crew Agent can't staff a flight, it triggers the Operations Agent to evaluate cancellation vs. delay, which then triggers Customer Agent for rebooking.
Why AgentCore Makes Sense: AgentCore is superior here because:
- Custom orchestration control: You need fine-grained control over which agent activates when, based on dynamic conditions (weather severity, passenger counts, crew availability)
- Agent-to-Agent communication: Direct A2A protocols let agents negotiate solutions without going through a central orchestrator bottleneck
- Flexible state management: You control conversation state, allowing agents to maintain context about the evolving disruption scenario
- Dynamic tool invocation: Tools aren't just API calls - they're intelligent decisions about which agent to activate next based on runtime conditions
- Performance optimization: You can implement parallel agent execution (e.g., Crew + Aircraft agents working simultaneously) rather than sequential Classic Agent tool calls
- Custom reasoning loops: Implement specialized reasoning patterns for time-critical decisions that differ from standard ReAct
The scenario demands real-time coordination, complex inter-agent dependencies, and custom orchestration logic that would be constrained by Classic Agent's managed framework.
Summary
With Amazon Bedrock, two different approaches for agent development are offered, each with different advantages and disadvantages
Classic Agents supply a completely managed, no-code option wherein you choose a base model and put on action groups. AWS seamlessly performs orchestration, reasoning loops, and prompt management. It is a perfect fit for simple workflows using well-defined tools like the document compliance system example, which where pre-built orchestration, native knowledge base integration, and managed session handling eliminate development overhead.
With the AgentCore Agents, you get an adaptable infrastructure that needs custom development, and it is open foundations which support the use of such frameworks as Strands Agents, CrewAI, and LangGraph. It is made for complicated situations where utmost control is desired—such as in the case of the multi-agent travel disruption system wherein custom orchestration allows for parallel agent execution, direct A2A communication, and dynamic coordination that would be restricted by Classic Agent's managed framework.
The main difference is that Classic Agents give priority to speed and simplicity for the standard workflows, while AgentCore provides the enterprise-level flexibility and control for the complex multi-agent architectures but at the same time, it increases the responsibility of development.
Enjoyed reading this content? Let the author know!
Your likes, comments, shares, and saves help creators reach more builders.
Loading recommendations
Loading article